Why Good Marketing Writers Are a Little Like Good Dentists

Apologies for the long hiatus from the blog. As many of you know, I went on an adventure for the first three months of this year (see the photo albums linked from the Appetizer course in the March issue of The Well-Fed E-PUB), and slowly getting back into the swing of things. Thanks for coming back!


So, I’m in the home stretch (the good news) of a dental implant procedure (the bad news). Thankfully, I feel like I’m in incredibly good hands with my dentist. She is so competent and knowledgeable, and does such a great job of explaining what she’s doing, making me comfortable during the process, and following up by phone after every step.

It’s a roughly 4+-month process, that began with an extraction of a tooth followed by the insertion of a titanium post screwed into the jawline. Actual powdered bone material is packed into the opening, and over the next four months, it assimilates into the jawbone, and further anchors the post. Finally, a prosthetic tooth attached to another screw, similarly, is screwed into the post.

(NOTE: As grisly and wince-inducing as the above description no doubt sounds, the whole process is basically a lot of sound and water, but no pain—except, of course, when it comes time to pay).

Consider the skill and expertise required to do the job at all, much less the masterful job she does. She is so good at what she does, and this process demands such a high level of expertise, that I’ve shelled out her non-trivial fee unhesitatingly, never considering for a second trying to get it done on the cheap. Just not worth it.

On the continuum of professional services—with those services you might consider “cheaping out” on, or even doing yourself, on one end; and those you’d never consider getting done by anyone but the best practitioner one can find, on the other—her services are obviously ensconced in the latter category.

Then, there are services that companies and individuals routinely put in the former category (i.e., those you might consider doing yourself), but don’t belong there in any way shape or form. And of course, professional copywriting services are one of them.

It’s Easy to Write, Right?
No mystery why this happens. After all, to the untrained eye, what’s so difficult about writing? It’s just stringing words together to form sentences that convey a certain message, right? Any educated, reasonably literate person can do it, yes? What’s so hard about it? Oh my, let us count the ways…

And because of the pervasiveness of this tragically misguided perception about the craft of marketing writing, it has the strange effect of actually convincing many writers of its veracity.

How else to explain why so many exceptionally good copywriters are insecure about their skills (not getting how so few can do what they do well), and lack the confidence to insist upon a professional wage—equivalent to the fees earned by other “professionals”?

Bad Writing Helps No One
Of course, that widely held misconception (i.e., of how “easy” writing is) doesn’t lose much power when so many mediocre writers flock to the field and keep cranking out pretty convincing evidence—for crappy wages—that writing actually is pretty easy.

After all, say the clients who pay those crappy wages, it must be easy, given how little we had to pay for it. I could have done just as good a job, but I don’t have the time. And that makes it tougher for the truly talented commercial writers (a.k.a. marketing writers) to convince many clients to pay those professional wages.

(NOTE: I’m not talking here about simple article-writing skills. If that’s all a client needs, then any number of thousands of writers out there have the basic skills to do an adequate job, and for pretty cheaply. I’m referring here to the more challenging marketing-copywriting skills held by far fewer people.)

They Don’t Know What They Don’t Know
At the heart of that challenge is the fact that those same clients have no idea what really good marketing writing looks like. What they see from the bargain-basement writers becomes their baseline perception, not only of what “good writing” should cost, but more importantly, what “good writing” is.

Hence, it becomes our job to educate them as to the difference it can make. No, if we have access to enough prospects who already understand the value of good marketing writing, and are willing to pay well for it, we don’t need to waste our time educating the unconvinced. But if those “enlightened” clients are in short supply in our prospecting pool, then educating may be in order (or, expanding one’s pool…).

Fact is, solid marketing copywriting takes a LOT of skill and expertise. It’s not easy, and by no stretch of the imagination can just anyone do it (tell you something you don’t know, right?). And if you are one of The Good Ones, I daresay it’s not a stretch to compare the caliber of your skills, in their own way, to those of a good dentist.


Have you wrestled with that typical writer insecurity that plagues so many of us?

Was there a moment (perhaps, a particular client/job) that had you realize you were delivering far more value to your client than just a “freelance writer” would?

Have you had clients contrast their experience working with you, with one working with a freelancer with little marketing background?

OR, have you had a client been hesitant to hire you, thanks to a past “bad-writer” experience?

Any other comments or observations?

Screen Shot 2017-05-05 at 12.56.37 PM
Speaking of good writing, I’ll be re-launching Well-Fed Craft—my popular program on how to actually write the most common commercial writing projects—on June 26. For all the details, go here.

Want to be a guest blogger on TWFW Blog? I welcome your contribution to the Well-Fed writing community! Check out the guidelines here.

5 replies
  1. Lori
    Lori says:

    Oh my, Peter. I’d no idea you were going through that! My husband just started that same process, though his involved not titanium, but cadaver bone. (Ew.) Good thoughts sent your way!

    My lord, we do think alike sometimes. I just went on a mild tangent about this very thing. I had seen someone saying that their client had convinced them to drop their rates because they were now able to write faster. How many ways this is wrong! We have to learn their business, their style, their vision and messaging… but I digress a bit.

    I have struggled with those insecurities, though not within the last seven or eight years. What turned it around for me was the moment I realized my specialized writing skill wasn’t something just any writer could handle. That was probably somewhere around 2005-2006. I can’t remember the specifics, but I remember the light bulb going off. Maybe it was when two favorite editors were telling me at a conference how I was their fourth staff member, or maybe when one of them said he had some reader complaining about how I needed to learn the industry before writing drivel he didn’t agree with — the editor said, “She doesn’t just know your industry, she f–king IS your industry.”

    Have I been compared to previous writers by clients? Absolutely. A current client said “I don’t know how you do it, but you get what I want to say. No one else has been able to.” She’s not the only one to hold me above other not-so-good marketing writers, and I’m grateful for each time it happens. It shows these people understand there’s more than just writing ability involved. We have to listen. We have to partner. We have to understand how each word will play out in front of the intended audience. We have to advocate for clients on what their marketing materials say about them.

    Oh, I’ve certainly had the “We’ve not had luck with writers in the past” concerns. I overcame them by doing what the others didn’t do — listen, research, and make sure what they asked for is what they got.

    I think your point on educating clients is exactly right — in some cases. Larger companies that haven’t worked with me and show signs of “easy work for the right person” syndrome are ones I’ll share my detailed process with. If they see it’s more than writing, they then see more of the value. Not that all of them are willing to open the vaults and pay what I’m asking, but they’ll go forward with a better understanding of what a quality writing relationship is and what the appropriate payment range might be.

  2. Peter Bowerman
    Peter Bowerman says:

    Great stuff,, I love it Lori! And yes, we clearly do see eye to eye on many things… 🙂

    The story about the writer who got talked into lowering their rates because they worked fast almost made me cry. That in fact, is one of the main reasons to be charging by the job, not by the hour: You get rewarded—not penalized—for working fast!

    And hey, can’t blame the client for asking! Well, I suppose you could, but we need to be our own best advocates for our bottom line. Clients will do what clients will do, but we have to be prepared to draw our line in the sand.

    And yes, it’s a really nice feeling to finally realize that what you are bringing to the table is not of the garden-variety. It’s certainly easy to believe that if it’s something that comes naturally to you (as writing does for many of us), but until we arrive at the point of understanding that our skills are uncommon, we will continue to let clients have their way with us.

    I love the comment your client made to the complaining reader! I have learned what you talk about, on many occasions—how, the more you work with the client, the more you learn their business, and the more valuable you become to them. AND, you often end up with a more holistic understanding of their business than anyone in the company!

    Personally, I love it when a prospect tells me they’ve had a bad experience with a writer(s) in the past. Sure, you have some doubts to overcome, but many of those previous writers have set such a low bar with their performance, reliability, and attitude (truly mind-blowing in many cases), that you’d be hard-pressed to not do a better job.

    It makes you wonder sometimes (and I’ve made this point in the past) whether many of those writers we hear of who apparently tried to make a go of freelancing and couldn’t do it, are many of the writers who left a bad taste in a client’s mouth. How surprising is it that that’s how it ended for them?

    And I absolutely agree about your definition of educating! A client may very well not know how the process will unfold, but if they were wise enough to realize they didn’t have the skills to accomplish their marketing goals, and to hire professional help, I’m all too happy to educate them… 🙂

    Thanks again for weighing in—your seasoned perspective is always valuable.

    And thanks for the well-wishes on the tooth stuff; got the new one in, and all is good!

  3. Peter Bowerman
    Peter Bowerman says:

    Sorry for the delay in responding – a lot of traveling!

    David, if you’re on the brink, it could be a useful step in the right direction. If you have any questions about the course, just reach out!

    And you’re welcome, Dan! Glad it helped. Making a living as a writer is very doable, but you have to treat it like a business, not a hobby (and I know you know that!)

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Optionally add an image